1. Dolphins show grief, elephants have burial rituals, primates demonstrate fairness concepts. Your premise that humans alone possess morality is demonstrably false.

2. Most scholars acknowledge these sources reference early Christian beliefs, not Christ himself. Josephus' key passage is widely considered a later Christian interpolation. Writing about a movement doesn't validate its central claims we have sources about Zeus worship too.

3. The Anaphora Pilati is a medieval forgery, not an authentic 1st-century document. No serious historian accepts it as genuine evidence. You're building on fabricated foundations.

4. Post-hoc rationalization. Gospel writers had access to Hebrew scriptures and crafted narratives to fit prophecies. Your statistical calculation assumes prophecies were specific and independent both questionable premises. Vague language allows retrofitting to almost any events. Not to mention there appear to be failed prophecies by Jesus himself.

5. People aren't always rational. People die for false beliefs regularly Heaven's Gate, Jim Jones followers, kamikaze pilots. Sincere conviction doesn't equal truth. Additionally, most apostolic martyrdom accounts are late, legendary developments with little historical support.