Replies: 8
| visibility 101
|
All-TigerNet [12675]
TigerPulse: 100%
Posts: 6341
Joined: 12/24/15
|
Afghanistan Was Not a Logistical Success
4
Mar 21, 2024, 7:49 AM
|
|
Gen Milley under oath testified yesterday that the Afghanistan evacuation was a "logistical success but a strategic failure."
While evacuating 120K people in a chaotic situation was probably done as well as possible under the circumstances, I would not characterize leaving behind many, many Afghan collaborators and some Americans as a logistical success.
Once again as in 2021, Gen Milley and McKenzie confirmed that Biden was advised to leave behind 2500 troops.
Biden said when asked about this in 2021 by George Stephanopoulos,"No.No one said that to me that I can recall." So either Biden's memory is indeed faulty or he lied. I'll go with the former which is just as troubling as a lie.
Once again as in past administrations, failure to listen to the military and allow them to control the process led to disaster.
It still appears unclear where the buck stops. Many errors regarding Afghanistan belong to other administrations including Trump's, but this botched withdrawal is Biden's and I seriously doubt the families of the fallen 13 troops would view the withdrawal as a "logistical success."
|
|
|
|
Orange Blooded [4024]
TigerPulse: 68%
Posts: 8086
Joined: 12/9/01
|
Re: Afghanistan Was Not a Logistical Success
Mar 21, 2024, 7:55 AM
|
|
So we should have stayed and everything would have been fine. There would have been 0 casualties in that case, correct?
|
|
|
|
|
All-TigerNet [12675]
TigerPulse: 100%
Posts: 6341
Joined: 12/24/15
|
Re: Afghanistan Was Not a Logistical Success
Mar 21, 2024, 8:20 AM
|
|
You got a ready supply of straw?
|
|
|
|
|
Orange Blooded [4024]
TigerPulse: 68%
Posts: 8086
Joined: 12/9/01
|
Re: Afghanistan Was Not a Logistical Success
Mar 21, 2024, 8:28 AM
|
|
No straw needed. How was this botched by Biden? What was a better solution that guarantees at least 13 soldiers would not gave died?
|
|
|
|
|
Oculus Spirit [97903]
TigerPulse: 100%
Posts: 64993
Joined: 7/13/02
|
Well, we still managed to do better than the Russians when they tried
Mar 21, 2024, 7:56 AM
|
|
That being said, you can't win a war if you can't win the peace.
|
|
|
|
|
All-In [47913]
TigerPulse: 100%
Posts: 44582
Joined: 9/5/02
|
the word success cannot be used in any way to describe what happened in
3
Mar 21, 2024, 8:16 AM
|
|
Afghanistan.
|
|
|
|
|
Orange Blooded [4846]
TigerPulse: 99%
Posts: 4882
Joined: 1/8/19
|
Re: Afghanistan Was Not a Logistical Success
Mar 21, 2024, 8:25 AM
|
|
Fustercluck is the word that comes to mind.
|
|
|
|
|
Legend [17394]
TigerPulse: 100%
Posts: 14319
Joined: 12/14/98
|
Trump negotiated the Doha Accord in Feb 2020 that called for full withdrawal
Mar 21, 2024, 8:56 AM
|
|
This deal did not include the Afghan government. It called for full US troop withdrawal by May 2021. It also reduced air support which was a precursor to rapid and complete collapse of Afghan military and government. It was a good deal for the Taliban, not so much for the US military and Afghan civilians who supported the US. Remember that the Trump administration negotiated the cut and run deal.
Biden’s administration compounded a bad deal but botching the execution. They were clueless on how quickly the Afghan regime would collapse and the ensuing chaos. Biden’s State Department was tardy on organizing civilian withdrawal ignoring intelligence and military reports. Biden and his Pentagon leadership had poor planning for the actual withdrawal especially civilians. It resulted in the chit show of August 2021.
There's plenty of blame to go around. It’s not easy to negotiate a surrender nor execute it with control and dignity.
|
|
|
|
|
All-TigerNet [12302]
TigerPulse: 100%
Posts: 5412
Joined: 9/12/04
|
I understand the line of thought on listening to our Military and I personally
3
Mar 21, 2024, 9:18 AM
|
|
think some of the 4 Stars should have thrown their stars on the table when the decision was made to give up Bagram Airbase before executing the complete/total evacuation of Afghanistan. If there was ever a moment in a military officers career where they must take a stand and tell the civilian leadership "this is a mistake and I will resign before carrying it out" this was it. But our 4 Star community consists of a whole lot of "go-along-to-get-along" people that don't want to rock the boat because it might affect their ability to stay in "the club" which directly impacts their "after the military" careers.
I'm still a bit unclear on "who" decided to close Bagram Airbase but from what I can tell it was the Sate Dept/NSA and the President signed off on it followed by a "yes sir" from Sec Def Austin and every 4 Star in the Afghanistan Chain (Milley, McKenzie, and Miller). These 4 Stars aren't stupid (well - perhaps Miller is but that is another story for another time) and they very well knew closing Bagram Airbase before the total evacuation was a huge tactical and strategic mistake. If they didn't then they are totally incompetent.
To be clear - my problem is not with the USA leaving Afghanistan (I personally think we should have left Afghanistan a few months after killing Bin Laden in 2011) as I was all for it. But when the military leadership "acquiesced" the timing, method and means of leaving Afghanistan to the likes of the State Dept and other Civilian "expert" advisors - they were absolutely derelict in their duty. They have a duty to not only speak "ugly" truth to the civilian leadership but to provide them with sound, militarily principled alternatives/methods to accomplish what the Civilian leadership has directed them to do. Sometimes they have to fight for those sound military principled alternatives/methods and I have yet to see that ever occurred in this Afghanistan evacuation.
I served with Milley when he was a senior Lieutenant Colonel and I was a "baby" Major. He was the epitome of what I call the intelligent "grunt knuckle dragger" that was a tremendously skilled war-fighter and a very effective combat leader. He was definitely not a political guy back then. Unfortunately the LTC Milley I served with has very little resemblance to the General Milley that I see today. To say that I've been utterly disappointed in him and his performance as the CJCS is an understatement.
PS...One last thought... Don't give the military leadership a pass on Afghanistan. For YEARS the Flag Officers had to know the Afghanistan military we were training was a hollow shell. If friends of mine doing the actual Afghan training knew it (and said so to their leadership) the Flag Officers in the leadership had to know as well. Yet for over a decade, the Flag Officers kept stringing Congress and multiple Administrations along with the "we are making steady progress" BS testimony making chicken shid sound like chicken salad.
None of these former Flag Officers have been held to account for their decades of misleading characterizations of the Afghan forces. They've never been forced to give a thorough explanation of how their characterizations were so wrong as to see the US trained and equipped Afghan forces totally collapse in less than 2 weeks of standing on their own. Twenty years of equipping and training to see it all collapse in 2 weeks to an Army of relatively untrained and lightly armed goat-herders is beyond ridiculous. This is a tremendous part of the problem we have in the military - no real accountability for the top ranks when they fail missions...
|
|
|
|
Replies: 8
| visibility 101
|
|
|