Clearly one of these guys is a total stud and deserves being discussed every 5 minutes as the Heisman Trophy voting prohibitive leader, and the other one isn't even 1st team all conference.
Even using ESPN's coveted "Eye Test" Henry is not as great an RB as his hype. He is very big, very strong and fast, but his vision is overage, his cuts are average, he has one "move" and that is to run over DBs (because DLs and LBs bring him down at the line of scrimmage.