It Should be 1.Alabama 2. Clemson 3. Georgia 4. Oklahoma. Those are the 4 best teams without a doubt. But the committee's logic is wrong.
So... by your logic a team loses a game (UGA) and moves up in the rankings over no loss teams. I can't recall anytime in the CFP era that a losing team moved up in the rankings for losing a game. If that is the case then why play the games at all? Just cut to the chase now and name the National Champ based on how they look and how people feel...