It’s really simple for me as to why the endless criticisms are…… A - a waste of time. B - unwarranted.
Reason A - you don’t get a say. The people that do get a say are both hyper competitive and highly incentivized to succeed. Reason B - endless criticism of the most successful Coach in Clemson history is just plain stupid. It looks stupid. It sounds stupid. I’d prefer to be nicer about it, but in order to be honest about it you have to call it what it is and that word is “stupid”.