Death Valley replica - on sale, 10% off!
Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?

  by - Senior Writer - Monday, May 6, 2013 12:13 AM

Photos: USA Today

Expectations for the season opener against Georgia are already high, but what looms as a battle between possible Top 10 or Top 15 teams with national implications also has an interesting sidenote to it: The game just might feature the best matchup of quarterbacks in Death Valley since Joe Montana and Notre Dame faced off against Steve Fuller and Clemson in 1977.

The game itself is still 116 days away, but the possibility of it being the site for ESPN’s GameDay, the closeness of the two schools, the rejoining of what was once a proud rivalry and the ACC-SEC implications, the game has already taken on the sheen of “must see.”

On November 12, 1977, a pair of top 15 teams met in Clemson’s Death Valley. A fifth-ranked Notre Dame team led by Montana defeated a 15th-ranked Clemson team led by Steve Fuller, 21-17. Both quarterbacks went on to become Super Bowl champions.

Notre Dame went on to win the national championship that season, and 36 players in that game went on to play in the NFL, including future Notre Dame Hall of Famers Ken MacAfee and Ross Browner. The Clemson roster that day included future NFL Pro Bowl players Dwight Clark and Jerry Butler.

However, the hype over those two quarterbacks wasn’t as great prior to that 1977 game because both Fuller and Montana were still juniors, and had another season to go.

However, the matchup between Boyd and Murray is one worth talking about, even though they won’t be on the field against each other and their battle isn’t truly head-to-head. Why? Because early mock drafts have both quarterbacks as possible first-rounders, something that has never been seen in Death Valley.

ESPN college football analyst Brock Huard says that Louisville’s Teddy Bridgewater is the top 2014 NFL draft prospect at the position, but has Boyd in the number two slot, with Murray coming in at third. On ESPN’s website, Huard writes of Boyd:

“Clemson's Chick-fil-A Bowl victory over LSU was the capper to a monster junior campaign that saw Boyd manage expectation, hype, his weight and the mechanics of a game in ways that NFL quarterbacks must do on a weekly basis. The fourth-most efficient passer in college football will be without some of the explosive firepower he had around him in 2012, including standout wide receiver DeAndre HopkinsDeAndre Hopkins
Wide Receiver
#6 6-2, 205
Central, SC

View Full Profile
(though both offensive coordinator Chad MorrisChad Morris
Offensive Coordinator / QBs
View Full Profile
and game-changing WR Sammy WatkinsSammy Watkins
Jr. Wide Receiver
#2 6-1, 205
Fort Myers, FL

View Full Profile

The number of sacks (31) and interceptions (13) conceded will be a focal point for the Tigers this fall, as will overall second-half production. Boyd's splits last season reveal a startling discrepancy between his first-half stats (26 TDs, 6 INTs) and second-half stats (10 TDs, 7 INTs).

Boyd became the face of Clemson's program in 2012 and has first-round upside heading into 2013. The LSU finale and the punishment Boyd endured while delivering in the clutch time and again turned heads. Plus, his third-down tape is better than any prospect in the 2013 class.

Clemson's opening game against Georgia will pit Boyd against the next top prospect on our list, Aaron Murray, and could serve as a platform to greatly boost one or both of their draft stocks.”

About Murray, Huard writes:

“The other senior-to-be in this top five made the wise decision to return to school and build upon a stellar 2012. Georgia offensive coordinator Mike Bobo made clear to Murray after the 2011 season that there were fundamental changes that needed to be made from the ground up, and Murray listened. He improved his footwork, developed better body control (both inside and outside the pocket), added strength and enhanced his accuracy in the intermediate-to-long passing game, netting Murray and the Bulldogs record-breaking numbers in 2012. Georgia set a school scoring record, while Murray passed for 3,893 yards and posted a 36-10 TD-to-INT ratio.

What brought Murray back to Athens for a fifth and final season? A combined 2-5 TD-to-INT ratio in games versus Alabama, Florida and South Carolina. The remaining question surrounding Murray isn't his productivity (he has amassed a total of more than 10,000 yards and 95 TDs) or his height. And it's not his gamesmanship, line-of-scrimmage mechanics or how he manipulates defenses -- all of which are NFL-caliber. Rather, Murray struggled to play his best in the biggest moments last season. In 2013, Murray will be immediately judged with battles against Clemson, South Carolina and LSU in three of the first four weeks.

Watch those games closely to see how he performs on third down, in the red zone and in the fourth quarter. NFL scouts and decision-makers certainly will be watching.”

With that in mind, I started thinking back to the best quarterback matchups that have been witnessed in Death Valley, and the Montana-Fuller was the one that jumped out to me first.

I contacted Clemson Sports Information Director Tim Bourret, and he said that the last matchup of future NFL quarterbacks in Death Valley was when Matt Ryan faced off against Charlie WhitehurstCharlie Whitehurst
#6 6-4, 225
Duluth, GA

View Full Profile
when Boston College played at Clemson in 2005.

Another good matchup was when Matt Schaub of Virginia faced off against Whitehurst, but there has never been a matchup of potential or future first round quarterbacks in Death Valley. Fuller was Clemson’s only first round quarterback selected by the NFL – he went to the Chiefs with the 23rd pick in 1979. Montana was actually a third round selection – 82nd pick – by the San Francisco 49ers that year.

The tickets for the Clemson and Georgia game will be a hot commodity, but Bourret might also have a tough time fielding all of the credential requests from NFL scouts and front office personnel.

The quarterback talent in the 2013 draft class was marginal, but 2014 figures to be a better year for signal callers across the board because of players such as Bridgewater, Boyd and Murray. In 10 of the past 13 years, the first pick in the draft has been a quarterback (the lone exceptions being Jake Long in 2008, Mario Williams in 2006 and Eric Fisher in 2013).

Boyd and Murray will certainly be playing for their teams and for bragging rights on August 31st, but both quarterbacks will also be under scrutiny from the folks at the NFL, and their performances on the big stage could have far-reaching implications.

As fans, however, we can just sit back and watch what might be the best quarterback battle ever seen in Death Valley. Will it be as good as the one between Fuller and Montana? Only time will tell.

In the meantime…..

Spot the ball.

Rate this Story:
14 votes
Send Feedback to David Hood: Email | Comment
    Morris talks South Carolina, Tyshon Dye and Deshaun Watson - 4 days ago
    Offensive coordinator Chad Morris met with the media Monday morning in the WestZone, and he said he understands the passion of the rivalry with South Carolina. What does he say about Tyshon Dye? What does he need to see out of Deshaun Watson this week in practice? Full Story »
    Morris says Stoudt has what it takes to beat South Carolina - 5 days ago
    Clemson and South Carolina renew acquaintances next Saturday at noon in Death Valley, and the biggest question surrounding Clemson’s offense centers on whether freshman quarterback Deshaun Watson will be able to play. If Watson isn't available, offensive coordinator Chad Morris thinks that senior Cole Stoudt has what it takes to lead Clemson to the win over the Gamecocks. Full Story »
    The Dye Is Cast - 5 days ago
    Tyshon Dye was cast into the fray Saturday and he responded with a big effort, notching 20 carries for 124 yards. What does he say about his big day? What do head coach Dabo Swinney and Chad Morris say about why Dye got so many carries? Full Story »
    Morris breaks down Watson's injury, a simple offense and Stoudt's confidence - 2 weeks ago
    Offensive coordinator Chad Morris faced the media Monday morning in the WestZone, and he answered a bevy of questions concerning the health of quarterback Deshaun Watson, the struggles of Cole Stoudt and the plan going forward. Full Story »
    Swinney says Stoudt "brings everything to the offense that we need to win" - 2 weeks ago
    Clemson head coach Dabo Swinney talked to media Sunday evening on his weekly teleconference, and he reiterated what he and offensive coordinator Chad Morris said in the aftermath of Clemson’s loss to Georgia Tech Saturday – no starter for next week’s game against Georgia St. has been named or will be named, but he thinks that senior Cole Stoudt still has everything it takes to lead the Tigers to victory. Full Story »

Post your comments!
Subject (Replies: 50) Author
Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?
TigerNet News®
Great article! Go TIGERS!***
Re: Seriously
Re: Seriously
Writer is uninformed with Boyds 2nd half stats
Re: Writer is uninformed with Boyds 2nd half stats
So more interceptions in fewer snaps is a good thing?!?***
Sorry, but you can't top Fuller vs Montana...
How is Aaron Murray overrated as a college QB?
0-3 vs SCar tells me he's overrated.
Re: Sorry, but you can't top Fuller vs Montana...
I think at this stage, Boyd and Murray are easily better QBs
Knocking Murray's arm strength and accuracy shows
Wrong, it shows I do know what I'm talking about….
You couldn't be more misinformed
and what makes you not a "layperson" ? i think you are an
sgt tiger®
Understanding the nuances of the game makes me not a laypers
Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?***
Re: Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?***
I was wondering when someone was going to call that.***
Re: Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?***
Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?
I hate when they only use stats like TDs and INTs. You have
I hate the comparison because the game has changed
Fuller vs Montana comes to my mind quickly *
Re: Fuller vs Montana comes to my mind quickly *
ND just lined up and ran the ball....
Montana kept throwing a little dump pass to their
Boyd and Murray are better QBs. They are both seniors and
Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?
Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?
He was the Georgia kicker who beat us with the 61 yd field
UGA PK Kevin Butler helped Fuller get the Super Bowl XX ring***
I'm really excited for this game.
um, they haven't played yet***
Montana is one of the greatest QB's ever and Fuller
That's "#### ball," David.
Who is Jeff Butler?
Both became Super Bowl champs but Fuller as a backup once.***
Seems odd Clemson never generated a star(ting) NFL QB.
Fuller started for a very bad Chiefs team for a few years***
Steve Fuller did start some in the NFL, although not a….
Re: Steve Fuller did start some in the NFL, although not a….
Re: Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?
Re: Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?
Re: I'm really excited for this game.
Re: Front Page Story: Boyd vs Murray: Best QB battle in Death Valley history?
Re: 0-3 vs SCar tells me he's overrated.
we are rivals. throw the record books out. the same can't be
sgt tiger®

Subscribe to our RSS Feed
Follow us on Twitter
Follow us on Facebook
Sign Up for News Alerts
Daily Digest